Why are people calling Iron Fist a white saviour, and what does it mean?

iron fist the defenders hd wallpaper danny rand finn jones catch up netflix marvel

Marvel’s latest Netflix drama Iron Fist released today – but it hasn’t been without controversy. For some time now, the show has been accused of falling into the white saviour narrative trope; from when the show was first announced, to the casting of Finn Jones as Danny Rand, and to the advance reviews, many people have focused on this complaint.

If you’ve been following the show at all, or you’re a fan of Marvel, you’ve probably heard about this. But what does it actually mean?

Here’s an article on Iron Fist, for the Metro.

(An important caveat – the above title is how I pitched the article to Metro. When the article was published, the headline was changed to say “Iron Fist: Marvel could have avoided a ‘white saviour’ and made the Netflix series better”, which I assume was just for the purpose of increasing views and so on. I don’t think this headline reflects the content of the article, which was intended more as an explainer than outright criticism – I haven’t actually watched a single frame of the show outside of trailers at this point. So, keep that in mind here.)

[Of course, another important caveat is that I do actually think Iron Fist should’ve cast an Asian American lead and it likely would have improved it a bit, but that’s not what the above is arguing.]

Facebook | Twitter | Blog Index | Superhero TV Index

TV Review: Primeval (1×06)

primeval logo hd itv science fiction dinosaurs nick cutter douglas henshall tim haines adrian hodges impossible pictures

The past has the habit of coming back these days, doesn’t it?

If we follow on from the idea presented last week – that Primeval is, fundamentally, a programme about unsustainable beauty, and nature fighting back against humanity – this finale episode becomes an obvious example of the past fighting the future.

It’s interesting to look at the future predator here, and to consider what it means. It was always the most iconic of the Primeval monsters; understandable, given that it was also one of the few original creatures. Certainly, it is an effective creature – this episode is a well-directed one, and far more tension was wrought from this one episode than have been in any of the preceding ones. There’s something about the future predator that does make it scary. Of course, it’s also the most well suited to Primeval’s fundamental premise – a literal representation of the danger presented by the future.

But then, however, when you look at the fight between the future predator and the Gorgonopsid, it’s the Gorgonopsid that eventually wins; the ultimate killing machine from the future can’t beat the past. It’s Primeval’s most blatant statement of intent – past is paramount. You can’t escape it. It’s always going to reassert itself, and it’s always going to win.

In that vein, Primeval certainly becomes a very cynical programme; the anomalies here a far more a representation of danger than of grace and beauty, with the attack of the future predators…

primeval nick cutter douglas henshall itv future predator gorgonopsid hd wallpaper tim haines adrian hodges claudia brown lucy brown

… and, of course, the disappearance of Claudia Brown.

It’s the great unsolved mystery of Primeval – one that positions the programme’s first series as a strange little oddity in its own right, at just enough of a remove from the rest of the show that it doesn’t quite fit alongside any other series. There’s various conflicting theories and assumptions as to what it all meant, how it happened, and why it was never explained; the most commonly accepted theory seems to be that Helen caused it somehow, or that it was a result of the baby future predators being left in the past, or something along those lines.

Both are wrong. The actual answer is this:

Claudia was taken by the anomalies.

It’s made clear from her dream – dream sequences rarely have dramatic merit in their own right, but at times the symbolism can be interesting. So, when we see Claudia’s reflection replaced – subsumed – by the anomalies, what does that mean?

It might simply be that this is the next stage; we’ve seen her largely abandon the bureaucracy she came from, acknowledging and embracing the beauty of the anomalies. Perhaps this is what happens next? (You can also note that both Nick and Connor, the other characters who came closest to engaging with this beauty, are wearing quite dark clothes, whereas Claudia is wearing brighter colours; the implication, presumably, is of a certain innocence and purity to her that they lack – making her ready for this ascendance?)

That doesn’t feel quite right though. More likely, perhaps, is that this was an act of foreshadowing rather than explanation – after all, while the above is an interesting idea, there’s actually very little to support it anywhere else in the programme. Instead, it might just be an indication that the anomalies will offer a reflection of Claudia in her place; that, of course, is Jenny Lewis.

primeval claudia brown lucy brown anomaly reflection arc itv impossible pictures

At the end of the day, though, there’s still not a lot to say about Primeval. It’s still difficult to call this particularly well-written television – there are certainly some egregious moments in this episode, though surely the crown must be handed to the shockingly poor throwaway revelation that Helen had an affair with Steven. It’s a very rushed reveal, which is handled quite poorly – and it diminishes the impact of the Claudia cliffhanger, which is where the focus should really be.

The fact is that Primeval actually isn’t all that good from a critical perspective. That’s not to say it isn’t fun or entertaining; after all, I’ve enjoyed watching each episode. But there’s just not a lot of depth here. Which is a shame, really, because there’s certainly the potential for that – often the show gestured at ideas that were quite interesting, and went deeper than what was on screen, but rarely followed them up or pursued them to their full extent.

To some extent, it’d be easy to write off the programme’s first series as a misstep – if you’re grading it all on the metric of characterisation and writing, that is. You can’t deny, though, that Primeval was often suspenseful, usually entertaining, and had some stunning CGI for its time. In that sense, then, the show is a success.

And in all fairness to it – I enjoyed myself. I think these reviews were worth writing, though I do suspect no one read them. And I think I’ll probably do series two next year – part of me wants to start watching it now, actually.

So, for all I criticised the show (and with the series roundup and graph coming next week, I suspect it’s due for some more critique in time) it’s worth remembering that it wasn’t so bad after all.



Primeval reviews

Facebook | Twitter | Blog Index | General TV Index